MDR vs SOC as a Service: Choosing the Right Cybersecurity Solution

MDR vs SOC as a Service: Choosing the Right Cybersecurity Solution
Vasanth Devisetty
Managing Director
Explore the differences between SOC and MDR in the cybersecurity landscape, delving into their roles, services, and impact on comprehensive digital defence.
MDR vs SOC as a Service: Choosing the Right Cybersecurity Solution

As a business in today's digital landscape, it is crucial to have a strong cybersecurity strategy in place. With the increasing number of cyber threats and attacks targeting organisations of all sizes, having robust security measures has become a necessity rather than an option.

Two popular solutions that businesses often consider for their cybersecurity needs are managed detection and response (MDR) and security operations centre (SOC) as a service. While both these services offer comprehensive security solutions, there are key differences between them that businesses need to understand in order to choose the right one for their specific needs.

In this article, we will delve into the nuances of MDR vs. SOC as a service, discussing their features, benefits, and differences to help you make an informed decision for your organisation.

Managed detection and response (MDR)

Managed detection and response (MDR) is a proactive cybersecurity service that provides organisations with continuous monitoring and threat detection. MDR service providers offer a team of cybersecurity experts equipped with advanced tools, including endpoint detection and response (EDR) software. These experts are dedicated to detecting and responding to security incidents swiftly.

MDR service provider

MDR providers focus on identifying and mitigating security threats with the help of machine learning and threat intelligence. They work to minimise response time, enabling a proactive approach to cybersecurity.

MDR goes beyond traditional security solutions, offering a comprehensive security package that includes threat hunting and incident remediation.

Key features of MDR:

  • Continuous monitoring of an organisation's security
  • Rapid detection and response to security incidents
  • Proactive threat hunting
  • Advanced EDR software
  • Minimised false positives in security alerts
Comparing SOC vs MDR for cybersecurity

Security operations centre (SOC) as a service

Security operations centre (SOC) is a central hub within an organisation responsible for monitoring the security of its digital infrastructure. SOC primarily focuses on monitoring security events and incident response. It collects and analyses security data collected across multiple security layers.

SOC as a service, or security operations centre as a service, is a cutting-edge solution that empowers organisations to bolster their cybersecurity defences efficiently. This service provides businesses with access to a dedicated team of security experts and state-of-the-art tools without the need for in-house infrastructure.

SOC as a service offers real-time monitoring of an organisation's digital assets, ensuring swift detection and response to security incidents. This proactive approach is vital in safeguarding against a myriad of cyber threats. By outsourcing their security needs to a SOC as a service provider, organisations can enhance their security posture, reduce risks, and maintain business continuity in an ever-evolving threat landscape.

SOC team

SOC teams, consisting of security analysts, monitor an organisation's network security, supervision, and security event detection. SOC analysts use security information and event management (SIEM) tools to identify and respond to security incidents promptly.

Key features of SOC:

  • Real-time monitoring of an organisation's security
  • Detection and response to security incidents
  • Utilisation of SIEM tools for security data analysis
  • Network security supervision
  • Focus on intrusion detection and incident response
Security experts discussing the level of security in SOC vs MDR

What's the difference between MDR vs SOC as a service?

Are you puzzled by the distinctions between SOC and MDR in the realm of cybersecurity? In this comprehensive listing, we'll unravel the key disparities between Security Operations Centers (SOC) and Managed Detection and Response (MDR) to help you navigate the complex world of digital defence.

1. Approach to security

MDR is a managed service, meaning it's outsourced to a third-party provider. This approach is ideal for organisations seeking a proactive security solution that can augment their existing in-house security team. On the other hand, SOC can be both in-house or outsourced. In-house SOC offers direct control over security operations, while outsourced SOC leverages the expertise of external service providers.

2. Focus on threat detection

MDR primarily focuses on rapid threat detection and response capabilities. It employs advanced technologies to identify and mitigate security threats promptly. In contrast, SOC focuses on monitoring and analysing security events and incidents, with an emphasis on network security supervision.

3. Level of expertise

MDR service providers typically employ a team of cybersecurity experts who specialise in analysing security data and responding to threats. SOC analysts are also experts in their field, but their focus is on using SIEM tools to detect and respond to security incidents.

The significance of distinguishing SOC vs MDR in the realm of cybersecurity

4. Security tool integration

MDR often integrates multiple security tools to provide comprehensive protection. In contrast, SOC primarily relies on SIEM tools and may not have the same level of tool integration as MDR services.

5. Proactive vs. reactive

MDR services take a proactive approach to security, using continuous monitoring and threat hunting to identify threats before they escalate. SOC, while capable of detecting threats, is more reactive, responding to incidents as they occur.

6. Scalability

MDR offers scalability to match the evolving needs of an organisation. SOC, especially in-house SOC, may require significant investment to scale effectively.

7. Comprehensive security

MDR solutions aim to provide comprehensive security, including threat detection, incident response, and threat hunting. SOC's primary focus is on monitoring security events and responding to incidents promptly.

Cybersecurity specialists working together to achieve comprehensive security in SOC and MDR

Making the right choice

The choice between MDR and SOC as a service largely depends on an organisation's specific requirements, existing security posture, and available resources. To make an informed decision, consider the following factors:

  • Organisational size: Smaller organisations with limited resources may find outsourced MDR or SOC services more cost-effective. Larger enterprises might opt for in-house solutions.
  • Existing security infrastructure: Evaluate the security tools and solutions already in place within your organisation. MDR can integrate seamlessly with existing security infrastructure, while SOC may require more effort to do so.
  • Threat landscape: Consider the nature of the threats your organisation faces. MDR is well-suited for organisations dealing with advanced and persistent threats, while SOC may suffice for those with less complex security requirements.
  • Budget and resources: Assess your available budget and the size of your security team. MDR services can be more budget-friendly for organisations with limited resources.
  • Compliance requirements: If your industry has strict compliance regulations, ensure that your chosen solution meets these requirements.
  • Response time expectations: If rapid response to security incidents is critical for your organisation, MDR may be the better choice due to its proactive approach.
Security professionals collaborating to protect against cyber threats in SOC and MDR

Enhance your cybersecurity with AccrueTek: MDR vs. SOC

In the battle against ever-evolving cyber threats, choosing the right cybersecurity solution is paramount. Managed detection and response (MDR) and security operations centres (SOC) both play crucial roles in securing an organisation's digital assets. The decision between the two ultimately depends on your organisation's unique needs, resources, and priorities.

If you want to improve your cybersecurity, it's essential to partner with a reliable service provider that offers comprehensive solutions, such as AccrueTek. Our team of experts stays on top of the latest cyber threats and trends to provide proactive protection against attacks.

Whether you need MDR for proactive protection or SOC for real-time monitoring, we've got you covered. Contact us at +44 1707 906128 or email sales@accruetek.com to make an informed choice and fortify your security posture in today's digital landscape.

An organisation's cyber security team discussing the impact of SOC and MDR on security posture


What is the difference between MDR and SOC as a service?

Managed detection and response (MDR) and security operations centre (SOC) serve distinct roles in the realm of cybersecurity. MDR focuses on proactive threat detection and response. In contrast, SOC specialises in real-time security monitoring. While both contribute to comprehensive cybersecurity, they differ in their approach and services.

What does "MDR" stand for, and how does it differ from SOC?

MDR stands for Managed Detection and Response. It's a cybersecurity service that combines comprehensive security services with the expertise of security professionals. MDR's primary objective is to provide proactive threat detection and response, minimising the impact of security incidents. In contrast, SOC is centred around continuous security monitoring, leveraging the expertise of security professionals.

How do SOC and MDR contribute to comprehensive cybersecurity?

Both SOC and MDR play crucial roles in achieving comprehensive cybersecurity. SOC focuses on monitoring and analysing security events and responding to incidents promptly. MDR stands for proactive threat detection and response, providing a proactive security posture. Combining these approaches ensures a robust defence against a wide range of cyber threats.

Can you elaborate on the roles of security professionals in SOC and MDR?

Security professionals are instrumental in both SOC and MDR. In SOC, these experts monitor an organisation's security events, analyse security data using security information and event management (SIEM) tools, and respond to security incidents as they occur. On the other hand, MDR employs security professionals to detect and respond to security threats swiftly and proactively. These experts use advanced tools and threat intelligence to protect against cyber threats effectively.

How do SOC and MDR services contribute to an organisation's security posture?

Both SOC and MDR services are essential for enhancing an organisation's security posture. SOC plays a vital role in real-time monitoring, allowing for immediate responses to security incidents. MDR takes a proactive approach, continuously monitoring for threats and employing proactive threat hunting. By combining these services, organisations can strengthen their security posture, effectively defend against threats, and ensure a safer digital environment.

Why is it important to understand the differences between SOC and MDR?

Understanding the differences between SOC and MDR is crucial because it enables organisations to make informed decisions regarding their cybersecurity strategies. By recognising the distinct roles and approaches of these services, organisations can align their security initiatives with their specific needs and objectives. This knowledge allows for more effective threat protection and helps ensure the security of sensitive data and digital ass

Back to blog